Watching Evolution

Some creationist somewhere is right now making the claim that, “In all the time scientists have been ‘watching’ for evolutionary change, they’ve never ‘caught’ a species transitioning into another one.” Well, the easy response to that remark is that all species, everywhere are in the midst of transitioning — the complicating factor is how damn slow it all is. So I decided to make a picture to bring some perspective to evolution’s immense sluggishness…

Notice the red spot in the top left corner of the image below. That is actually a scaled representation of how long we’ve been on the “look-out” for evolutionary changes, about 150 years. On the scale that we’re working on here, you can see that 150 years appears almost as a dot, but it does have a little length. You can see that the red portion is at the end of a longer, squigglier line that ends at the box labeled “Homo sapiens,” that’s the point on this timeline where our species first showed up (about 200,000 years ago). The next even longer and squigglier line terminates at a box labeled “Homo erectus.” In the current “species” discussions around human evolution, Homo erectus is considered to be our direct previous ancestor, originating about 1.8 million years ago.

Now Homo erectus is very similar to modern humans. It had a brain about 74% the size of Homo sapiens, its forehead is less sloping, and its teeth are smaller — otherwise, not a lot of difference. So consider that timeline. If we wanted to “witness” a change such as the increasing brain size between Homo erectus and Homo sapiens, we would have to be “watching” for the same period of time we have been — times 12,000. 

We are not going to see something like an ape giving birth to a human, not ever — no matter how long we watch. Actually, if you see that, get down on your knees and pray, because you have just seen a real miracle and the best evidence for God, ever.

As a footnote, I should mention that over the summer Richard Lenski published a paper in which an E. coli strain he had been working with continuously for twenty years evolved an ability to ingest citrate. Since the lack of citrate transport is considered a defining characteristic of the E. coli species, we may have finally “caught” just such a species-to-species transition in the act. Creationists have been unimpressed — but then, they are the ones waiting for a baby to be born from a gorilla.


5 Responses

  1. Question…sometimes changes occur in such a slow and subtle way so the viewer can not notice these changes as they occur but would be able to notice if the time was removed and only before and after was shown, right? So when we watch the progress of a plant growing the video is sped up so that we can see the painstaking slow process in mere seconds…If a creationist was watching in real time this plant growing I wonder would they notice when the very first itsy bitsy bit of the plant starts to emerge from the soil and also be able to make a note of every moment of change? Or would they blink and then say that it wasn’t there and now it is and voila, another miracle from God.

  2. Actually, what they do is something even sillier. They distinguish between “micro-evolution” and “macro-evolution.” They will openly admit that micro-evolution occurs, but that it is never “enough” to make a species-to-species transition. So they will admit that the plant started to emerge, but will call that only a “variation” of the seed. They cannot seem to grasp that many micro-changes makes a macro-change.

  3. Great illustration! Should be shown in every school system!

  4. Excellent summation!

    As someone else once said (don’t remember who – help anyone?), if evolutionary history were compressed to a single year, we would not have arrived until 2PM on December 31st.

  5. […] was then featured in Evolution Blog’s Carnival of Evolution for this snazy diagram illutstrating the sluggish pace of evolution. That was nice for us since EB is a highly-frequented blog and Jason Rosenhouse is a pretty cool […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: