I was reading a recent blog post by Dinesh D’Souza in which he manages two such flagrantly appalling misapplications of logic, that I feel compelled to review them…
The first is an example of the backwards Appeal to Nature fallacy that I pointed out the other day. I think I will start referring to this as the “Unappeal of Nature” fallacy. The typical Appeal to Nature fallacy is usually employed to make moral judgments about acts based on their natural- or unnatural-ness. That which occurs in nature is considered “good” and that which does not is “bad.” When it comes to evolution, however, the fallacy is twisted in an odd way.
As an argument against the acceptance of evolution D’Souza states:
Nazis repeatedly invoked Darwinian evolution and that Nazi doctrine used “survival of the fittest” as a virtual recruiting phrase.
Linking evolution to Nazis is a fairly common technique of creationists. The general argument follows these lines: Continue reading
Filed under: Evolution, Logic, Religion | Tagged: D'Souza, Dawkins, Evolution, Logic, Nazis | 6 Comments »